Since its premiere in November 2019, Welcome to Plathville has chronicled Lydia Plath’s journey alongside her family. However, fans are now voicing their concerns, accusing Lydia of being “fake” despite her deep-rooted faith.
Lydia’s Personal Growth
Throughout the series, the Plath family has been portrayed as having a unique upbringing, distinct from many mainstream American families. Lydia has consistently been depicted as a devout follower of Christ, often retreating to prayer during family turmoil. Her kindness and compassion have made her a pivotal figure, especially in helping to care for her younger siblings. Even when she began to explore her independence, such as talking to boys, she quickly returned to the teachings of her parents, Kim and Barry Plath.
In Season 6, Lydia has shown signs of personal growth, spending time with her sister Moriah and contemplating attending college. While she is clearly evolving and seeking her own beliefs, some fans are questioning her authenticity.
Backlash Over Perceived “Fake” Behavior
On Reddit, discussions have erupted regarding a significant shift in Lydia’s online presence. One user noted, “Lydia changed her Instagram subscription option,” revealing that she now charges $5 a month for exclusive content. Following a post that hinted at an engagement announcement, fans felt this was a disingenuous move, describing it as “engagement bait.” The vague message accompanying a photo of her holding hands with someone led to rampant speculation.
Comments ranged from confusion about the subscription model to outright criticism. One user remarked, “I don’t mean to be rude, but when I watch her, it seems like she’s vacant, like there are little moths fluttering in her head.” Others sarcastically pointed out the absurdity of charging for content, with one saying, “Did she also say why anyone would want to pay to follow her life when watching paint dry is still free?”
Lydia’s Response to Rumors
Despite the backlash, Lydia is attempting to clarify her situation. In her Instagram Stories, she posted a video to dispel rumors about an engagement, revealing that she was wearing a promise ring on her right hand. However, the “big news” remains exclusive to paying subscribers, prompting her to encourage fans to subscribe quickly to avoid missing out.
As one user noted, “I hadn’t heard it was clickbait. What was the actual ‘big news’?” The ambiguity surrounding her announcements has only fueled the speculation and skepticism.
Conclusion
As Welcome to Plathville continues, Lydia Plath finds herself at a crossroads, navigating her personal growth while facing backlash from fans. Whether she can reconcile her evolving identity with the expectations of her audience remains to be seen. The upcoming season promises to explore these dynamics further, but for now, the conversation around Lydia is more critical than ever.